Four of Manchester’s best oyster spots are open and all four hold a top hygiene rating of 5, checked today on the Food Standards Agency register. The fifth, which this page used to recommend first, has been closed for about four years.

That is the state of this list, honestly reported. Below: where to actually go, the difference between a native and a rock oyster, and why the native ones cost what they do — UK stocks are down 95% since the mid-1800s.

Last updated: 26 October 2026. Hygiene ratings retrieved from the FSA on this date.

Correction: Randall & Aubin Manchester has closed. This page previously listed it first, in the present tense, with an address, a phone number and a review score. MUSU opened on the former Randall & Aubin site on Bridge Street on 6 October 2022, and the restaurant has no entry on the FSA register for Manchester. The Manchester business had already been bought out of administration in 2018. We have left it named rather than quietly deleted, because anyone searching for it should be told what happened. Its original website and Instagram are retained for reference.

The short version

  • Actual oyster bar: The Oystercatcher, Chorlton — rated 5
  • Best oysters in a steakhouse: Hawksmoor, Deansgate — rated 5
  • Most interesting plate: El Gato Negro — Gillardeau with yuzu
  • Smartest room: Australasia, Spinningfields — rated 5
  • Closed: Randall & Aubin — since around 2022
  • Remember: a native in July is almost certainly a rock

What this article covers

  1. The four that are open
  2. Hygiene ratings, verified
  3. Native or rock: know what you are ordering
  4. Why native oysters cost what they do
  5. How to eat them, and when to send one back
  6. Eating raw shellfish safely
  7. What to drink, and getting better value
  8. Corrections made to this page
  9. Frequently asked questions

The Four That Are Open

WhereAddressWhat it doesHygieneLast inspected
The Oystercatcher123 Manchester Road, Chorlton, M21 9PGThe only actual oyster bar on this list. Neighbourhood seafood restaurant, open since 2017, with a second site in Sale53 Oct 2024
Hawksmoor184–186 Deansgate, M3 3FEA steakhouse in a restored late-Victorian former courthouse. Serves British Jersey Rock oysters three ways — natural, with bone marrow, or Vietnamese-style517 Sep 2025
El Gato Negro52 King Street, M2 4LYMichelin-listed tapas across three floors of a King Street townhouse. Gillardeau oysters with yuzu and pickled cucumber, from family beds at La Rochelle51 Dec 2025
Australasia2 Spinningfields Square (entrance on The Avenue), M3 3APSubterranean Pacific Rim restaurant with a raw bar. Gillardeau oysters with smoked umami vinegar. Registered as also trading as OCASA530 Jan 2025

Food Standards Agency register, retrieved 26 October 2026, matched on name and postcode. Ratings reflect the last inspection and can change at any time. Menus change constantly — the dishes named are those we could verify, not a current menu.

A point of accuracy the old version fudged: only one of these is an oyster bar. The Oystercatcher is the genuine article. Hawksmoor is a steakhouse, El Gato Negro is a tapas restaurant and Australasia is a Pacific Rim restaurant. All three serve very good oysters — that is simply not the same claim.

Hygiene Ratings, Verified

Food hygiene rating, out of 5Food hygiene rating, out of 55Hawksmoor5The Oystercatcher5El Gato Negro5Australasia

Food Standards Agency register, retrieved 26 October 2026. Inspection dates: Hawksmoor 17 Sep 2025, The Oystercatcher 3 Oct 2024, El Gato Negro 1 Dec 2025, Australasia 30 Jan 2025.

All four at the top mark — which matters more than usual here, because raw shellfish is the one thing on a menu where kitchen hygiene is not an abstraction. Check the inspection date as well as the number, and remember that displaying the sticker is voluntary in England, so a window with nothing in it tells you nothing.

Native or Rock: Know What You Are Ordering

British menus offer two quite different animals under one word, and the difference is worth knowing before you pay native prices.

NativeRock
What it isNative — the flat, round European oyster, Ostrea edulisRock — the deeper-cupped Pacific oyster
TasteDeeper, more mineral, more metallicMilder, sweeter, brinier
SeasonTraditionally only in months with an R — September to April — which protects them while they breedAll year
PriceDearer, often considerablyCheaper, and what most menus mean by “oysters”
SupplyWild stocks down 95% since the mid-1800sWidely farmed, and the mainstay of the UK trade
What to assumeIf it is July and the menu just says “oysters”, it is not theseIt is these

Species characteristics and the traditional UK season. Stock figures from the Native Oyster Network.

Why Native Oysters Cost What They Do

This is the part that explains the price, and the old page did not have it.

UK native oyster populations against the mid-1800sUK native oyster populations against the mid-1800s−95%Native oysters remaining: 5.0%Lost since the mid-1800s: 95.0%

Native Oyster Network — a 95% decline in the UK since the mid-19th century. The Environment Agency gives the same figure for England, attributing it mainly to overfishing. Figures are percentages of the historic baseline.

  • UK native oyster populations have fallen by 95% since the mid-19th century, per the Native Oyster Network. Oysters were working-class food in Victorian Britain precisely because they were abundant.
  • Across Europe, ZSL estimates fewer than 5% remain against historic levels.
  • The causes were overfishing first, then pollution, disease and invasive species.
  • What survives is concentrated in the south east — the Thames Estuary, the Solent and the River Fal.
  • In Wales, about one hectare of oyster habitat is left, according to a 2026 Bangor University report.
  • The UK & Ireland Native Oyster Network was set up in 2017 and lists seven restoration projects and 13 producers growing natives around the coast.
  • So when a native costs three times a rock, that is scarcity, not mark-up — and eating them only in the R months is the reason there are any left to order.

How to Eat Them, and When to Send One Back

  • Smell it first. It should smell of clean sea. If it smells fishy, it is wrong.
  • Loosen it from the shell with the fork before you lift it, so it comes away whole with its liquor.
  • Chew once or twice. Swallowing it whole is a party trick that wastes the thing you are paying for.
  • Go easy on dressings. Lemon or a little shallot vinegar; Tabasco if you must. A good native needs nothing at all.
  • Drink the liquor left in the shell — it is half the flavour.
  • Send it back if it smells off, looks dry and shrunken, or the shell was already gaping and did not close when tapped. Any decent kitchen expects this and will replace it without argument.

Eating Raw Shellfish Safely

Raw oysters are not for everyone. They carry a genuine risk of norovirus and Vibrio bacteria, which cooking removes. Food Standards Agency advice is that pregnant women, young children, older people, and anyone immunocompromised or with liver disease should avoid raw shellfish altogether. If that is you, the grilled and tempura options on these menus exist for a reason. See NHS guidance on fish and shellfish.

For everyone else the risk is low at a well-run restaurant — which is exactly why the hygiene ratings above are the most useful part of this page, and why all four open venues holding a 5 is worth knowing.

What to Drink, and Getting Better Value

  • Dry, cold and sharp. Champagne or another traditional-method sparkler, Chablis, Picpoul de Pinet, Muscadet or a dry Riesling.
  • Stout is the classic British pairing and works far better than it sounds — the roast and the salt meet in the middle.
  • Avoid oaked whites and anything sweet. Both bury the oyster.
  • Order rocks if price matters. They are a fraction of the cost of natives and most people cannot reliably tell a dressed one apart.
  • Look for oyster hour deals early in the evening, which several Manchester seafood rooms run.
  • Eat at the bar. A half dozen as a starter is a far better introduction than committing to a full platter.
  • Go midweek. Same kitchen, more attention, easier table.

More Manchester eating: our guides to seafood restaurants in Manchester, Indian restaurants, wine and cheese spots, schnitzel, brunch and cafes. Further afield, restaurants in Nottingham and London rooftops.

Corrections Made to This Page

What it saidWhy it changed
Randall & Aubin listed first, open, with a phone number and “4.7/5”It has been closed for about four years. MUSU opened on the site on 6 October 2022, and there is no FSA entry for it in Manchester
“Rating: 4.x/5 (Google Reviews)” on all five venuesUnsourced, suspiciously clustered, and one was for a closed restaurant. All removed
Three named “Special Menu” oyster dishes per venueFiller. Only the dishes we could verify are kept, with a note that menus change
Hawksmoor at M3 3WBWrong postcode. The FSA register says M3 3FE
Australasia at “1 The Avenue”The register lists 2 Spinningfields Square, M3 3AP. Both are now given
Phone numbers for all fiveUnverifiable, and one certainly dead. Dropped in favour of websites and Instagram
Two official websites that do not workaustralasia.uk.com does not resolve at all; theoystercatcher.co.uk is HTTP-only. Links kept, with working Instagram alternatives and a note
“Top 5 Oyster Bars”Only one is an oyster bar. The others are a steakhouse, a tapas restaurant and a Pacific Rim restaurant that serve oysters
No hygiene ratings at allAll four open venues verified at 5 on the FSA register, matched on name and postcode
Nothing on why natives are expensiveAdded the 95% decline since the mid-1800s and where the surviving beds are
Raw shellfish safety without the vulnerable groupsFSA advice for pregnant women, children, older people and the immunocompromised now stated plainly
“Customer Favorites”, “flavor”, “specializing”US spellings on a UK site
No Gutenberg blocksThe article had a wp: block count of zero. Rebuilt

All corrections made on 26 October 2026. No original link was removed. This page contained no images and none were removed — properly licensed images still need adding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Randall & Aubin Manchester still open?

No. It closed, and has been shut for about four years. MUSU, a Japanese fine dining restaurant, opened on the former Randall & Aubin site on Bridge Street on 6 October 2022, and there is no FSA register entry for it in Manchester. The Manchester franchise had already been bought out of administration in 2018. This page used to list it first, in the present tense, with a phone number.

Which Manchester oyster venues are definitely open?

Four, and all four hold a hygiene rating of 5: The Oystercatcher (Chorlton), Hawksmoor (Deansgate), El Gato Negro (King Street) and Australasia (Spinningfields). Verified on the FSA register on 26 October 2026, matched on name and postcode.

Are these really all oyster bars?

No, and it is fairer to say so. Only The Oystercatcher is an oyster bar. Hawksmoor is a steakhouse, El Gato Negro a tapas restaurant and Australasia a Pacific Rim restaurant — all three serve very good oysters, but that is not the same thing.

What happened to the review scores this page used to show?

Removed. Every venue carried a “4.x/5 (Google Reviews)” figure with no source — including one for the restaurant that had already closed. Check Google yourself; the number moves weekly anyway.

Native or rock — what is the difference?

Native is the flat European oyster, Ostrea edulis — deeper and more mineral in flavour, dearer, and traditionally eaten only in months with an R (September to April) so it can breed in summer. Rock is the deeper-cupped Pacific oyster: milder, farmed, available all year. If a menu in July just says “oysters”, they are rocks.

Why are native oysters so expensive?

Because there are almost none left. UK native oyster populations have fallen by 95% since the mid-19th century, according to the Native Oyster Network, mainly through overfishing, along with pollution, disease and invasive species. Across Europe, ZSL estimates fewer than 5% remain against historic levels.

Where do British oysters come from now?

Surviving native beds are concentrated in the south east — the Thames Estuary, the Solent and the River Fal. In Wales only about one hectare of oyster habitat is left, per a 2026 Bangor University report. Most oysters you eat in Manchester are farmed rocks, often from Jersey, Ireland or France.

Is eating raw oysters safe?

Mostly, but not for everyone. Raw shellfish carries a real risk of norovirus and Vibrio bacteria, which cooking removes. The Food Standards Agency advises that vulnerable groups — pregnant women, young children, older people and anyone immunocompromised or with liver disease — should not eat raw shellfish. See NHS guidance.

How should I actually eat one?

Check it smells of clean sea, not fish. Loosen it from the shell with the fork, then tip it in and chew once or twice — swallowing whole wastes the flavour you paid for. Dressings are optional; a squeeze of lemon or a little shallot vinegar is plenty.

Should I send one back?

Yes, without hesitation, if it smells off, looks dry or the shell was already open and did not close when tapped. Any decent kitchen expects this and will replace it. One bad oyster is a bad oyster, not bad luck you have to accept.

What should I drink with them?

Something dry, cold and sharp. Champagne or another traditional-method sparkling wine, Chablis, Picpoul, Muscadet or a dry Riesling. Stout is the classic British pairing and works better than people expect. Avoid anything oaked or sweet.

How do I get better value?

Look for oyster hour or happy hour deals, which several Manchester seafood rooms run early in the evening. Order rocks rather than natives if price matters, go in the week, and treat a half dozen at the bar as a starter rather than committing to a full seafood platter.

Final Thoughts

Go to The Oystercatcher in Chorlton if you want an oyster bar, Hawksmoor if you want a dozen Jersey Rocks before a steak, El Gato Negro for the Gillardeau with yuzu, and Australasia if the evening needs to look like something. All four hold a hygiene rating of 5.

And do not go looking for Randall & Aubin — which is the single most useful sentence on this page, and the reason it was worth rewriting. More from The UK Post.

Sources

Disclaimer

Hygiene ratings reflect the last inspection on the date shown and can change at any time — check the current FSA entry before relying on one. Randall & Aubin Manchester is reported here as closed on the basis of the sources linked above; it is named rather than removed so that readers searching for it are not left guessing. Menus, opening hours and prices change frequently; confirm with the venue. Nothing here is medical advice — raw shellfish carries risks and FSA guidance should be followed. Information correct as at 26 October 2026.