Four of the five venues on this list are open and all four hold a top hygiene rating of 5. The fifth — listed here at number two, in the present tense, with a menu and a rating — closed four years ago.
Manchester’s seafood is better than its reputation, but it is scattered: a neighbourhood oyster room in Chorlton, a grand hotel dining room, a Cantonese kitchen that does whole steamed fish properly, and a seafood bar inside a bigger restaurant.
Last updated: 27 October 2026. Hygiene ratings retrieved from the FSA on this date.
Correction: Randall & Aubin Manchester has closed. MUSU opened on the former Randall & Aubin site on Bridge Street on 6 October 2022, the Manchester business had already been bought out of administration in 2018, and it has no FSA register entry in Manchester. This is the second guide on this site that was recommending it — which is how one stale recommendation spreads. It is named here as closed rather than quietly deleted, so anyone searching for it is told.
The short version
- Actual seafood restaurant: The Oystercatcher, Chorlton — rated 5
- The room: Mount Street at The Midland — rated 5
- The food: Wing’s, Lincoln Square — rated 5
- The scene: The Ivy Spinningfields — rated 5
- Closed: Randall & Aubin, since 2022
- Raw shellfish: not for pregnant, older or immunocompromised
- Allergies: crustaceans and molluscs are separate
What this article covers
The Five, and Which Still Exist
| Venue | Where | What it is | Hygiene | Last inspected |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Oystercatcher | 123 Manchester Road, Chorlton, M21 9PG | The actual seafood restaurant on this list. Oysters, small plates, neighbourhood room | 5 | 3 Oct 2024 |
| Mount Street Dining Room | The Midland, M60 2DS | Grand hotel dining room. Rating is for The Midland Hotel, the registered premises | 5 | 18 Sep 2025 |
| Wing’s Restaurant | Lincoln Square, M2 5LN | Cantonese, and long-established. Strong on steamed fish and lobster | 5 | 18 Dec 2024 |
| The Ivy Spinningfields | The Pavilion, Spinningfields, M3 3HG | The seafood bar sits inside the wider restaurant | 5 | 31 May 2026 |
| Randall & Aubin | Bridge Street | CLOSED. MUSU opened on the site on 6 October 2022 | — | No register entry |
Food Standards Agency register, retrieved 27 October 2026, matched on name and postcode. Ratings reflect the last inspection and can change at any time.
A point of accuracy the old page fudged: only one of these is a seafood restaurant. The Oystercatcher is the genuine article. Mount Street is a hotel dining room, Wing’s is Cantonese, and The Ivy’s seafood bar sits inside a much broader menu. All serve very good seafood — which is a different claim.
- The Midland’s rating is listed under the hotel (M60 2DS) because that is the registered premises. A rating belongs to a premises, not a restaurant name.
- The Oystercatcher’s working website is theoystercatcher.org. Our oyster bars guide links the
.co.ukdomain, which does not resolve over HTTPS — both are retained, but this is the one that works. - Wing’s is the one locals name when asked where to eat fish in Manchester, and it rarely appears on lists like this.
- Book at weekends for Mount Street and The Ivy. Chorlton is easier.
Hygiene Ratings, Verified
Food Standards Agency register, retrieved 27 October 2026. The Oystercatcher M21 9PG (3 Oct 2024), The Midland Hotel M60 2DS (18 Sep 2025), Wing’s Restaurant M2 5LN (18 Dec 2024), The Ivy Spinningfields M3 3HG (31 May 2026).
Food Standards Agency register and trade press reporting of the Randall & Aubin closure, 27 October 2026.
Check the inspection date as well as the number. The Ivy’s 5 is from May 2026 and The Oystercatcher’s from October 2024 — both top marks, describing kitchens nineteen months apart. Displaying the sticker is voluntary in England, so an empty window tells you nothing.
Which One, and Why
- The Oystercatcher, Chorlton — the one to pick if seafood is the point rather than the setting. Open since 2017, with a second site in Sale. Rated 5.
- Mount Street Dining Room, The Midland — for an occasion. Grand room, formal service, and the hotel kitchen holds a 5 on its September 2025 inspection.
- Wing’s Restaurant, Lincoln Square — Cantonese, and the best place in the city for whole steamed fish and lobster. Rated 5.
- The Ivy Spinningfields — the seafood bar inside a bigger room. Reliable rather than remarkable, and busy. Rated 5 on its May 2026 inspection, the most recent here.
- For oysters specifically, our Manchester oyster bars guide goes further, including the native-versus-rock distinction.
Raw Shellfish, Safely
Raw shellfish is not for everyone. The NHS advises that if you are older, pregnant or have a weakened immune system you should avoid raw or lightly cooked shellfish — and that includes young children. Cooking removes the risk, which is exactly why the grilled and tempura options are on the menu.
| Point | The position | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Who should avoid raw shellfish entirely | People who are older, pregnant or immunocompromised — and young children, per the NHS. Cooking removes the risk | NHS |
| What the risk actually is | Norovirus and Vibrio bacteria, which filter-feeding shellfish concentrate from the water they grow in | FSA |
| Why oysters specifically | They are eaten alive and raw. Nothing in the process kills anything | NHS |
| Shellfish allergy | Crustaceans and molluscs are two separate entries among the 14 regulated allergens — a prawn allergy and a mussel allergy are not the same thing | FSA |
| Cross-contamination | Shared fryers and shared ice are the usual routes. Say “allergy” rather than “I don’t eat” | FSA |
| Send it back | If it smells fishy rather than of clean sea, or a shell was already open and did not close when tapped | — |
NHS and Food Standards Agency guidance, read 27 October 2026.
The reason oysters are a special case: they are filter feeders eaten alive and raw, so they concentrate whatever is in the water they grow in and nothing in the process kills it. That is why harvesting areas are classified and monitored — see FSA shellfish controls. At a well-run restaurant the risk is low, which is why the hygiene ratings above are the most useful part of this page.
Choosing Sustainable Seafood
- Look for the blue MSC label — MSC UK publishes which fisheries are certified, and a kitchen using certified fish will usually say so.
- Ask where the fish came from. A restaurant that cannot tell you is telling you something, and good kitchens enjoy the question.
- Eat the less fashionable species. Hake, coley, mussels and mackerel are abundant, cheap and better value than cod or tuna.
- Farmed is not automatically worse, and wild is not automatically better. It depends entirely on the fishery or the farm.
- Mussels are the easy win — rope-grown mussels are among the lowest-impact animal protein you can order.
- Avoid anything described only as “white fish”. A kitchen that will not name the species has not thought about where it came from.
Seasonality, and the R Months
- Native oysters: September to April — the months with an R — which protects them through the summer breeding season.
- Rock oysters are farmed and available all year. If a menu in July just says “oysters”, they are rocks.
- Scallops are best in the colder months, and sweeter for it.
- Mackerel and sardines peak in late summer, when they are both cheapest and best.
- Crab is a spring and summer proposition; lobster runs through the warmer months.
- A menu that offers everything all year is buying frozen or flown, which is fine — but worth knowing.
More of the city: our guides to oyster bars, sushi bars, omakase, steakhouses, Indian restaurants, halal restaurants and restaurants worth travelling for.
Corrections Made to This Page
| What it said | Why it changed |
|---|---|
| Randall & Aubin listed at number 2, open, with a menu and a rating | It has been closed for about four years. MUSU opened on the site on 6 October 2022 and there is no FSA entry in Manchester. This is the second guide on this site that listed it |
| A “Rating:” figure on every venue | No source, no scale — and one was for a closed restaurant. The sixth page in this batch with this pattern |
| No hygiene ratings at all | Four verified at 5 on the FSA register, matched on name and postcode |
| All five presented as seafood restaurants | Only The Oystercatcher is. The others are a hotel dining room, a Cantonese restaurant and a seafood bar inside a broader menu |
| Sustainability advice with no source | MSC UK and FSA shellfish controls now linked |
| Shellfish safety without naming who should avoid it | NHS advice for older people, pregnant women, the immunocompromised and young children now stated plainly. Crustaceans and molluscs are also two separate allergens |
| “Fresh Flavors” in the title, “Customer Favorites” five times | US spellings on a UK site |
| No Gutenberg blocks, no tables, no structured data | The article had a wp: block count of zero. Rebuilt, with FAQ JSON-LD |
All corrections made on 27 October 2026. All five images and every original link were kept, including the Randall & Aubin website.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Randall & Aubin Manchester still open?
No. It closed, and has been shut for about four years. MUSU opened on the former Randall & Aubin site on Bridge Street on 6 October 2022, the Manchester business had already been bought out of administration in 2018, and it has no FSA register entry in Manchester. It was listed here at number 2, in the present tense.
Which Manchester seafood restaurants are actually open?
Four, and all four hold a hygiene rating of 5: The Oystercatcher (Chorlton), Mount Street Dining Room at The Midland, Wing’s Restaurant (Lincoln Square) and The Ivy Spinningfields. Checked on the FSA register on 27 October 2026, matched on name and postcode.
Are these all seafood restaurants?
Only The Oystercatcher really is. Mount Street is a grand hotel dining room, Wing’s is a Cantonese restaurant with excellent fish, and The Ivy has a seafood bar inside a broader menu. All serve very good seafood — that is not the same claim, and the old page did not make the distinction.
Why is the Midland’s rating listed under the hotel?
Because that is the registered premises. Mount Street Dining Room sits inside The Midland, and the FSA rates the hotel kitchen (M60 2DS, rated 5, inspected 18 September 2025). A rating belongs to a premises, not a restaurant name.
What happened to the ratings this page used to show?
Removed. Every venue carried a “Rating:” figure with no source and no scale stated — and one of them was for a restaurant that had already closed. That is the sixth page in this batch with the same problem.
Who should not eat raw oysters?
The NHS is explicit: if you are older, pregnant or have a weakened immune system, avoid raw or lightly cooked shellfish — and that includes young children. See NHS guidance. Cooking removes the risk, which is why grilled and tempura options exist.
What is the actual risk with raw shellfish?
Norovirus and Vibrio bacteria. Oysters and mussels are filter feeders, so they concentrate whatever is in the water they grow in. That is why harvesting areas are classified and monitored — see FSA shellfish controls.
Is a shellfish allergy one allergy?
No, and this trips people up. Crustaceans (prawns, crab, lobster) and molluscs (mussels, oysters, squid) are two separate entries among the 14 regulated allergens. Someone can react to one and not the other. Shared fryers and shared ice are the usual cross-contamination routes.
How do I choose sustainable seafood?
Look for MSC certification — the blue label — and ask the kitchen where the fish came from. MSC UK publishes which fisheries are certified. A restaurant that cannot tell you where its fish is from is telling you something.
Does the “R months” rule still apply?
To native oysters, yes — and for a real reason. Native oysters are traditionally eaten from September to April, which protects them through the summer breeding season. Rock oysters, which are farmed, are available all year — so if a menu in July just says “oysters”, they are rocks. See our Manchester oyster bars guide.
Should I send a bad oyster back?
Yes, without hesitation. If it smells fishy rather than of clean sea, looks dry, or the shell was already gaping and did not close when tapped. Any decent kitchen expects this and will replace it.
Which is best for an occasion?
Mount Street at The Midland for the room, The Ivy Spinningfields for the scene, Wing’s for the food if you want steamed whole fish done properly, and The Oystercatcher if you actually want a seafood restaurant. All rated 5.
Final Thoughts
The Oystercatcher if seafood is the point, Wing’s if the cooking is, Mount Street if the room is. All four open venues here hold a hygiene rating of 5, which at this end of the market is reassuring rather than surprising.
And do not go looking for Randall & Aubin — which is the most useful line on this page, and the second time we have had to write it. More from The UK Post.
Sources
- Food Standards Agency — food hygiene rating search
- NHS — fish and shellfish, including who should avoid raw shellfish
- Food Standards Agency — shellfish controls information
- Food Standards Agency — food allergy and intolerance guidance
- Marine Stewardship Council UK — certified sustainable seafood
- The Manc — MUSU opening on the former Randall & Aubin site
- Harden’s — Randall & Aubin Manchester bought out of administration (2018)
Disclaimer
Hygiene ratings reflect the last inspection on the date shown and can change at any time — check the current FSA entry. Randall & Aubin Manchester is reported as closed on the basis of the sources linked above; it is named rather than removed so readers searching for it are not left guessing. Raw shellfish carries a genuine risk of norovirus and Vibrio, and the NHS advises that older people, pregnant women, those with weakened immune systems and young children avoid it. Nothing here is medical advice. Crustacean and mollusc allergies are distinct — always speak to staff directly. Menus and opening hours change; confirm with the venue. Information correct as at 27 October 2026.