A dense, fudgy Southern chocolate chess pie with a fine crackled top — in cups and grams, at UK oven settings, with the quantities this page was previously missing altogether.

Chess pie is one of the oldest desserts in the American South: a baked custard of eggs, sugar and butter with barely any liquid, thickened by egg and given structure by a spoonful of cornmeal. Angus Barn in Raleigh, North Carolina has served a chocolate version for decades, and it is the dessert people remember longest about the place.

Not the restaurant’s recipe. Angus Barn does not publish one. This is a traditional Southern chocolate chess pie written to match the texture and balance people describe. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or approved by Angus Barn.

Last updated: 26 October 2026.

At a glance

  • Makes: 8 slices, 23cm (9in) pie
  • Prep: 20 minutes
  • Bake: 45–55 min at 180C / 160C fan / gas 4
  • Setting: 2 hours out, then chilled — about 4 hours total
  • Gluten-free? Only with cornmeal and a GF case
  • Keeps: 3–4 days chilled, 2 months frozen
  • Best: made a day ahead

What this article covers

  1. Ingredients, with quantities
  2. Method
  3. UK conversions and oven settings
  4. What is actually in the filling
  5. How to tell when it is done
  6. Troubleshooting
  7. The real history of Angus Barn
  8. Corrections made to this page
  9. Frequently asked questions

Ingredients, With Quantities

A slice of chocolate chess pie on a plate

Image source: Pinterest.com

IngredientAmountNotes
Deep pie case1 × 23cm (9in)Shop-bought deep-dish is fine. Use a gluten-free case if that matters
Granulated or caster sugar300g (1½ cups)Not icing sugar — it will not give the crackled top
Unsweetened cocoa powder20g (¼ cup)Cocoa, not drinking chocolate, which is mostly sugar and milk powder
Fine cornmeal (or plain flour)20g (2 tbsp)Fine polenta works. Cornmeal keeps the filling gluten-free; wheat flour does not
Fine salt¼ tspKeeps the chocolate from tasting flat
Large eggs3, at room temperatureCold eggs can seize the melted butter
Dark chocolate100g, melted and cooled50–60% cocoa solids. This is what makes it fudgy rather than merely sweet
Unsalted butter115g (1 stick), melted and cooledCooled, or it will scramble the eggs
Evaporated milk120ml (½ cup)Tinned, in the baking aisle. Not condensed milk, which is sweetened
Vanilla extract2 tspExtract rather than flavouring if you can

Metric weights converted using King Arthur Baking’s ingredient weight chart and rounded to practical kitchen amounts.

Method

A whole chocolate chess pie with a crackled top

Image source: Pinterest.com

180C
160C fan / gas 4
45–55
minutes in the oven
50p
size of the wobble when done
2 hrs
maximum at room temperature
  1. Heat the oven to 180C / 160C fan / gas mark 4 and stand the pie case on a baking tray. The tray makes it possible to move a wobbling pie without wearing it.
  2. Melt the chocolate and butter together — 30-second bursts in the microwave, or a bowl over barely simmering water — then leave them to cool to barely warm. This step is the one people rush, and hot fat scrambles eggs.
  3. Whisk the sugar, cocoa, cornmeal and salt together in a large bowl, making sure there are no cocoa lumps.
  4. Add the eggs one at a time, whisking until the mixture is smooth and the sugar no longer feels gritty between your fingers.
  5. Stir in the cooled chocolate and butter, then the evaporated milk and vanilla, until glossy and even. Do not whip air into it — you want a dense custard, not a mousse.
  6. Pour into the case and bake for 45–55 minutes. It is done when the edges are set, the surface is matte with a fine crackle, and only a 50p-sized wobble remains in the middle.
  7. Cool at room temperature for up to two hours, then move it to the fridge to finish setting — about four hours in total before it slices cleanly. It is an egg custard, so it should not sit out longer than that.

UK Conversions and Oven Settings

Chocolate chess pie filling being whisked

Image source: Pinterest.com

American recipes measure by volume, which is the single biggest source of error when baking one in a UK kitchen. Weigh instead.

What one US cup actually weighsWhat one US cup actually weighs198gGranulated sugar120gPlain flour84gCocoa powder156gCornmeal226gEvaporated milk

King Arthur Baking — ingredient weight chart. Cornmeal is the yellow figure; whole cornmeal is about 138g.

  • 1 stick of butter is 113g — roughly half a standard UK 250g block.
  • 350F is 177C exactly, so set 180C, 160C fan, or gas mark 4. This page previously said “about 155 fan”, which is not a setting on any oven.
  • Fan ovens run hotter — the rule of thumb is 20C below the conventional figure.
  • Use cocoa powder, not drinking chocolate. Drinking chocolate is mostly sugar and milk powder and will not work here.
  • Evaporated milk, not condensed. Evaporated is unsweetened; condensed is not, and this filling already has 300g of sugar.
  • Fine polenta stands in for cornmeal and is easier to find in UK shops.
  • Oven dials drift. A cheap oven thermometer settles more baking arguments than any recipe tweak — much like the kit choices in our look at food storage containers.

What Is Actually in the Filling

A baked chocolate chess pie cooling

Image source: Pinterest.com

The filling by weightThe filling by weight865gSugar: 34.7%Eggs (3 large): 22.0%Evaporated milk: 13.9%Butter: 13.3%Dark chocolate: 11.6%Cocoa: 2.3%Cornmeal: 2.3%

Calculated from the quantities in this recipe. Three UK large eggs are taken as about 190g shelled.

Sugar is over a third of the filling by weight, and that is not a mistake to correct. Chess pie is meant to be dense and sweet — it was built for kitchens without refrigeration, where sugar and fat did the preserving. Cut smaller slices rather than reducing the sugar, which will stop the crackled top forming.

How to Tell When It Is Done

  • The edges are set and no longer liquid.
  • The surface is matte with a fine crackle. A glossy, wet-looking top means it needs longer.
  • Only a 50p-sized wobble remains in the centre when you nudge the tray.
  • Nothing sloshes. A wave moving across the middle means underbaked.
  • A fine crackle is right. Deep cracks or a sunken crater mean overbaked. The two are often confused, and this page used to describe cracking as both correct and a fault within the same article.
  • It will still look slightly soft, and that is fine — an egg custard keeps cooking in its own heat after it leaves the oven.

Troubleshooting

A pastry case ready for filling

Image source: Pinterest.com

ProblemCauseWhat to do
Loose, wet centreUnderbaked, or cut before it had setChill it — it firms up considerably. Next time bake until only a 50p-sized wobble remains
Deep cracks or a sunken craterOverbaked. A fine crackle is correct; deep splits are notTake it out while the centre still wobbles slightly
Grainy or gritty textureSugar never dissolvedWhisk the sugar into the eggs properly before the fat goes in
Greasy layer on topButter was too hot and split outLet the butter and chocolate cool to barely warm
Soggy baseA homemade all-butter case needed blind bakingBlind bake a homemade case for 15 minutes; a shop-bought deep case usually does not need it
Pale topOven running coolCheck with an oven thermometer. Dials drift by 10–20C

Standard baking causes and fixes for an egg-set custard pie.

The Real History of Angus Barn

Chocolate chess pie cut to show the dense centre

Image source: Pinterest.com

Worth getting right, because this page had it wrong — and the true version is better.

Angus Barn, Raleigh
1959 – Thad Eure Jr. and Charles Winston buy about 50 acres of pastureland off US-70 for $6,750
1959 – Banks refuse to lend. Eure’s father, Thad Eure Sr. — North Carolina’s long-serving Secretary of State — mortgages his own home to guarantee the loan
28 Jun 1960 – Angus Barn opens, built on a barn motif modelled on Winston’s grandfather’s barn, serving Angus steaks
1978 – Eure buys Winston out
1988 – Thad Eure Jr. dies; his wife Alice and daughter Van become co-owners
Today – Van Eure runs the restaurant with her husband Steve Thanhauser
Apr 2026 – Florence “Flo” Winston, the last surviving co-founder, dies at 90

The chocolate chess pie fits that history: a dessert that has barely changed because it already does what it needs to. For more on where recipes come from, see our pieces on foods that start with K, foods beginning with L and foods beginning with V.

If you want more to cook from, try our one-pan British weeknight dinners, quick British lunches, easy plant-based British recipes and this vegetable lo mein. For pudding out rather than in, there is always afternoon tea in London.

Corrections Made to This Page

What it saidWhy it changed
An ingredient list with no quantities at allThe recipe could not be followed. Full amounts in cups and grams added
“The filling contains no flour by default, making it naturally gluten-free”Misleading, and it matters. The list offered “cornmeal or flour”, and a standard pastry case is not gluten-free either
“Blind baking is not required” vs “a soggy base means the pastry needed blind baking”Direct contradiction. Resolved: not needed for a shop-bought case, worth doing for a homemade one
Cracking described as both correct and a faultDirect contradiction. Resolved: a fine crackle is right, deep cracks mean overbaked
“Cool completely at room temperature” / “cooling time 3–4 hours” vs “no more than two hours”Direct contradiction on a food-safety point. Resolved: up to 2 hours out, then chilled
Evaporated milk given a UK sourcing noteIt was not in the ingredient list or the method. Now in the recipe, with a quantity
“Founded by Thad Eure Sr.”Wrong. Founded by Thad Eure Jr. and Charles Winston; Eure Sr. was the father who mortgaged his home to fund it
“175 degrees Celsius (about 155 fan)”Not a setting on any oven. Now 180C / 160C fan / gas mark 4
No Recipe structured dataA recipe page had none. Recipe and FAQ JSON-LD added
“center”, “flavor”, “signaling”US spellings on a UK site

All corrections made on 26 October 2026. All images and original links were kept.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did this page have no quantities before?

It listed ingredients by name only — “granulated sugar”, “large eggs” — with no amounts, so the recipe could not actually be followed. Full quantities in cups and grams are now given above.

Is this the official Angus Barn recipe?

No. Angus Barn does not publish one. This is a traditional Southern chocolate chess pie built to match the texture and balance people describe — not affiliated with or endorsed by the restaurant.

Is chocolate chess pie gluten-free?

Only if you make it so. The filling is gluten-free if you use fine cornmeal rather than wheat flour — and the pastry case must be gluten-free too, which a standard one is not. This page previously called the filling “naturally gluten-free” while also listing flour, which was misleading. If you are cooking for someone coeliac, check every component and see Coeliac UK.

What oven temperature in UK terms?

180C, 160C fan, or gas mark 4. American recipes say 350F, which is 177C exactly — but no UK dial reads that, so 180C is what you set. This page previously said “about 155 fan”, which is not a setting on any oven.

Do I need to blind bake the crust?

Not for a shop-bought deep case — the filling is thick enough that the base cooks through. Do blind bake a homemade all-butter case for about 15 minutes, which is the usual cause of a soggy bottom.

Is the cracked top a mistake?

A fine crackle is exactly right — it is the sign the custard has set. Deep splits or a sunken crater mean it was overbaked. That distinction is the bit most recipes leave out.

How long can it sit out?

Up to two hours. It is an egg-and-dairy custard, so after that it belongs in the fridge — in line with Food Standards Agency chilling guidance. It keeps covered in the fridge for three to four days, or frozen tightly wrapped for up to two months.

Can I use condensed milk instead of evaporated?

No. Condensed milk is heavily sweetened and would make the pie cloying on top of 300g of sugar. Evaporated milk is unsweetened and sold in tins in the baking aisle.

Can I use cocoa only, and skip the chocolate?

You can, but it will be a different pie — drier and less fudgy. The melted chocolate is the whole point of this version. If you leave it out, add about 15g more cocoa and 25g more butter.

What is chess pie, and where does the name come from?

A baked custard of eggs, sugar and butter with very little liquid, thickened mainly by egg and given structure by a spoonful of cornmeal. It comes from the American South and predates home refrigeration. The name’s origin is genuinely unknown — “chest pie” and “jes’ pie” are both folk explanations, and neither is documented.

Who actually founded Angus Barn?

Thad Eure Jr. and Charles Winston, who opened it on 28 June 1960. Thad Eure Sr. was the father, North Carolina’s long-serving Secretary of State, who mortgaged his home to put up most of the money after banks refused to lend. This page previously credited the father as founder.

Can I make it ahead?

Yes — it is better made a day ahead. The texture firms and the chocolate flavour deepens overnight in the fridge. Slice it cold with a hot, dry knife.

Final Thoughts

Chess pie is forgiving in the ways that matter and unforgiving in one: it needs to cool before you cut it. Bake it until only a 50p-sized wobble is left, give it two hours out and then the fridge, and it will slice into clean, dense wedges with a fine crackled top.

Make it the day before. The texture firms and the chocolate deepens overnight, and it is one of the very few puddings that is genuinely better for the wait. More from The UK Post.

Sources

Disclaimer

This recipe is not the Angus Barn recipe and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the restaurant, which does not publish one. If you are cooking for anyone with a food allergy or coeliac disease, check every ingredient and the pastry case yourself — a filling made with cornmeal is gluten-free but a standard pie case is not. Storage and cooling advice follows Food Standards Agency guidance. Information correct as at 26 October 2026.

Chocolate chess pie served with cream

Image source: Pinterest.com

Chocolate chess pie on a kitchen worktop

Image source: Pinterest.com